The closing article of Volume II of the Inflammation Series — on the discipline that decides whether everything in the previous articles was money spent or money invested.
By Lisa Martin, Ballymoon Farm
Every article in this volume has added something: a ration rebuilt on forage, an omega-3 with a stated job, amino acids for the aging pony, zinc and vitamin E against quiet deficiencies, a gut product held to an honest standard.
This closing article is about the question that should follow each of them out of the feed room:
How will I know whether it worked?
It sounds simple. In practice it is the step most feeding programs skip entirely — and a program that skips it drifts, year by yfear, into a shelf of half-remembered reasons, fed out of habit at real expense. The supplement industry does not require us to evaluate. Our horses deserve that we do it anyway.
An intervention can only be judged against an outcome named in advance, and the outcome has to be something more specific than “doing better.”
p>For a ration change aimed at an easy keeper, the honest outcomes are measurable ones: body weight on a tape, body condition score, a cresty neck score — the 0-to-5 scale we examined in The Cresty Neck Conundrum — moving, or deliberately not moving, over a stated period.
For a skin horse on omega-3s, it might be the state of the coat and the itch at the same point next season compared with a photographed record of this one. For the aging pony on amino acids, topline photographs in the same light. For a metabolic horse, the least sentimental measure of all: insulin, tested under comparable conditions, discussed with your veterinarian. What bloodwork can and cannot establish was Volume I’s careful subject in Measuring the Invisible, and its cautions apply here in full — a marker is a clue, not a verdict, and a trend measured the same way each time is worth more than any single number.
If the outcome cannot be named, that is information too. It usually means the product is being fed on hope, and hope is not a feeding program.
The second discipline is sequence.
Change the forage, start the balancer, add the omega-3, and begin the gut product in the same month, and any improvement that follows belongs to all four and therefore to none of them. You will feed all four forever, at four prices, because you can no longer tell which one earned its place.
One change at a time costs patience and buys knowledge. It also asks for a fair trial: coat and hoof changes are measured in months, condition in weeks to months, and a supplement abandoned at ten days was never tested at all — only sampled. At the other extreme, a product still being fed two years after its trial, with no record of what it was for, has not passed a test either. It has merely been forgotten in the affirmative.
Our own habits here are unglamorous and written down: condition and girth recorded monthly for the horses we are actively managing, a dated photograph for the filly whose recovery we are following, and the herd’s health calendar carrying the deworming, vaccination, and hoof-care dates alongside the notes. Memory is a storyteller. A record is a witness.
Even a disciplined trial runs into the truth that horses are not experiments.
Seasons change under your feet — a skin horse improves as the insects die back whether or not the supplement helped, which is precisely why our own allergy mare’s program is judged across seasons and not within one. A growing filly improves because she is growing. An aging pony declines, sometimes, because he is aging, and no ration was ever going to vote against time. Regression to the mean — the plain statistical fact that things measured at their worst tend to look better at the next measuring — flatters more supplements than any ingredient in them.
None of this makes evaluation futile. It makes it humble. The aim is not laboratory certainty, which a barn cannot produce. The aim is to be able to say, with a straight face and a notebook: this changed, in this direction, over this period, and here is what else was happening at the time.
The final discipline is the willingness to stop.
A product that has had its fair trial, at its proper dose, against its named outcome, and has nothing to show, should leave the feed room — kindly, without drama, and without being replaced by the next tub making the same promise. Volume I ended on the principle that good treatment begins with diagnosis, in When Inflammation Becomes Chronic. The feeding version is its twin: good feeding begins with observation, and it continues only where observation says it should.
What remains, when the shelf has been pruned to what earns its place, is a ration you can defend line by line — which is where this volume began: forage first, the balancer as the meal, each addition with a job, a dose, and a review date.
Feed the horse. Not the fire. And keep the records that prove you know the difference.
—
The Inflammation Series — Volume II: Treating Inflammation from the Inside Out
1. Carter RA, et al. (2009). Apparent adiposity assessed by standardised scoring systems and morphometric measurements in horses and ponies. The Veterinary Journal, 179(2), 204–210. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tvjl.2008.02.029
2. Equine Endocrinology Group. (2022). Recommendations for the Diagnosis and Management of Equine Metabolic Syndrome.
3. Durham AE, et al. (2019). ECEIM consensus statement on equine metabolic syndrome. Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine, 33(2), 335–349. https://doi.org/10.1111/jvim.15423
Educational information only. Evaluation of a horse who is losing condition, lame, or unwell belongs with your veterinarian, not with a supplement trial.
Ballymoon Farm
Connemara Sport Horses & Ponies
The Connemara Breeder’s Library — by Lisa Martin
For more of our latest photos and inspiration, follow along on instagram at @instapony_.
© Redbud Ranch 2020 | Connemara Sport Horses and Ponies | photos by Lisa Martin |
terms & Condtions |
privacy Policy
Intentionally Bred with People in Mind
Browns Valley, CA
+ Show / Hide Comments
Share to: