Intentionally Bred with  People in Mind

Browns Valley, CA

BALLYMOON FARM

Management, Feeding & Nutrition

Why Timothy Is the Gold Standard in Hay for Feeding Horses

November 11, 2026

Watercolor illustration of a flake of soft, leafy, pale green timothy hay

Disclosure: I earn a small commission if you buy through my Mad Barn link, at no extra cost to you โ€” and you can take 5% off with my code 5%-OFF-FROM-LISA-M at checkout. I only link products I actually feed. Blue and Ruby eat AminoTrace+ every day. Shop through my Mad Barn store.


If you ask ten horse people what hay to feed, you’ll hear ten different answers. But ask what hay everything else gets compared to, and the answer is almost always the same: timothy.

Timothy isn’t the richest hay. It isn’t the cheapest hay, and it isn’t the softest or the sweetest. What it is, is the steady one โ€” moderate in just about everything, high in the fiber horses actually need, and consistent enough that you can build a whole feeding program on it and then adjust around the edges. That’s why it’s called the gold standard. Not because it’s perfect for every horse, but because it’s the baseline everything else is measured against.

What timothy actually is

Timothy (Phleum pratense) is a cool-season grass hay, grown mostly in the northern United States and Canada. A good bale is fine-stemmed, green to pale green, leafy for a grass hay, and smells clean and sweet โ€” not dusty, not musty, not bleached out by sun.

It’s a grass hay, not a legume like alfalfa. That one difference drives most of what follows: less protein, less calcium, less energy per pound than alfalfa, and a lot more room to feed enough forage without overshooting.

The numbers, in plain terms

These are typical ranges for timothy, not a lab result for any one lot. Every cutting is different, and that’s the first thing to understand about hay: the name on the bale tells you the species, not the analysis.

Typical timothy range
Crude protein7โ€“11%
Digestible energy~0.88โ€“0.95 Mcal/lb
Fiber (NDF)60โ€“70%
Calcium~0.20โ€“0.40%
Phosphorus~0.20โ€“0.30%
NSC (sugar + starch)Highly variable, often 10โ€“15% โ€” test the lot

Compare that with alfalfa, which runs roughly 16โ€“20% protein, about 1.5 times the energy of timothy, and around 1.3% calcium โ€” about four times timothy’s. Orchard grass sits in between on energy and is often a little softer and sweeter, which is why picky eaters tend to prefer it.

Timothy’s moderate protein is the point. Most adult horses at maintenance or in light work don’t need 18% protein. Extra protein doesn’t build extra muscle โ€” it just has to be processed and peed out, and in a horse that runs hot or holds weight easily, the extra calories that come with it are the real problem.

Why the fiber matters most

A horse is built to eat fiber all day. The hindgut ferments fiber, and that fermentation is what keeps the gut moving, keeps the horse warm from the inside in winter, and keeps a horse occupied instead of bored and fence-chewing.

Timothy is high in structural fiber โ€” the long, stemmy fiber that takes time to chew and time to ferment. That chewing matters: more chews mean more saliva, and saliva buffers stomach acid. A horse eating a flake of timothy slowly is doing its gut a favor that a scoop of grain never will.

That’s also why timothy works so well for easy keepers. You can feed a generous amount of it โ€” enough to keep the horse busy and the gut full โ€” without the calorie load that the same weight of alfalfa or rich orchard grass would bring. It’s one of the few hays that can often be fed free-choice without as much worry about weight gain, though “often” is doing a lot of work in that sentence, and an easy keeper still needs weighing and watching.

The calcium-to-phosphorus balance

Timothy’s calcium-to-phosphorus ratio runs roughly 1.5:1 to 2:1, which is right in the range most horses need. Alfalfa’s calcium is so high that the ratio can run 5:1 or more, and when the forage is already that skewed, the balancer and the rest of the diet have to work harder to bring it back.

That doesn’t make alfalfa bad. It makes alfalfa a tool for horses that need it โ€” growing horses, lactating mares, hard keepers, horses in heavy work. For a maintenance horse, timothy’s balance is simply easier to build on.

What timothy is not

This is where the “gold standard” label can mislead, so let’s be straight about it.

Timothy is not automatically low sugar. Its NSC is highly variable and depends on the weather, the time of day it was cut, and how mature the plant was โ€” not just on the species. A late-cut timothy on a sunny afternoon can test higher in sugar than an early-cut orchard grass. If you have a metabolic horse, an insulin-dysregulated horse, or a laminitis-prone horse, the name on the bale is not enough. Test the lot.

Timothy is not a complete diet. No hay is. Timothy is low in some things horses need every day โ€” salt, vitamin E once hay is cured and stored, and the trace minerals that depend on your soil and your region. That’s why a forage balancer, salt, and vitamin E sit alongside the hay in my barn, not instead of it. The hay is the foundation; the balancer fills the gaps the hay leaves. The section below is the one I use here.

What fills the gaps timothy leaves: AminoTrace+

Timothy does the heavy lifting โ€” the fiber, the bulk, the steady calories. What it doesn’t do is tell you exactly how much copper, zinc, manganese, selenium, magnesium, or vitamin E is in any given lot. Those levels move with the soil, the cutting, and the curing, and the species name on the bale doesn’t guarantee any of them. That’s the gap a balancer is for, and the one I feed is Mad Barn’s AminoTrace+.

Here’s how it lines up with timothy, point for point:

  • Trace minerals the hay doesn’t promise. A full 200 g serving of AminoTrace+ โ€” the dose for a 500 kg (1,100 lb) horse โ€” supplies 750 mg zinc, 300 mg copper, and 150 mg manganese, in organic proteinate form. Timothy can be short or variable on all three, and those are the minerals tied to hoof, coat, and skin quality. The balancer gives me known amounts instead of a guess.
  • Vitamins cured hay loses. Once hay is cut, cured, and stored โ€” and once the pasture is done for winter โ€” vitamin E fades fast, and vitamins A and D aren’t guaranteed either. AminoTrace+ supplies 1,250 IU of natural vitamin E (d-alpha-tocopherol), 30,000 IU of vitamin A, and 5,000 IU of vitamin D3 per 200 g. That’s the winter gap, covered in the same scoop.
  • The limiting amino acids. Timothy’s crude protein can look adequate on paper while still being short on the amino acids that limit topline and muscle โ€” lysine, methionine, and threonine. AminoTrace+ adds 10 g lysine, 6 g methionine, and 5 g threonine per 200 g, plus 20 mg biotin. It doesn’t turn timothy into alfalfa; it just means the protein the horse does get is more usable.
  • Magnesium and selenium, without piling on iron. Each 200 g serving carries 11 g magnesium and 2 mg selenium (as selenium yeast), with no added iron and a low-NSC formula โ€” so it doesn’t undo the moderate-sugar advantage of a grass-hay ration. It also includes yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) and MOS for gut support.
  • It doesn’t replace the salt, or the hay test. AminoTrace+ contains some salt, but not a full day’s worth โ€” Blue and Ruby still get their 1 oz of table salt on top. And it doesn’t replace testing a lot for a metabolic horse. What it does is make the timothy base consistent: the same known minerals and vitamins every day, whatever the cutting, so I’m not re-balancing the ration every time a new load of hay arrives.

That’s how I use it here: Blue and Ruby are both on the full 200 g a day of AminoTrace+ under our shared diet โ€” 1 lb Triple Crown Senior, 30 g monosodium phosphate, 30 mL KER EO-3, 1 oz salt, and the balancer โ€” with 5 lb timothy and 5 lb alfalfa each as the forage base. The rest of the herd is still finishing Symphony before they switch over, so for now the timothy-plus-AminoTrace+ combination is Blue and Ruby’s, not the whole herd’s.

If you want to try the same balancer, it’s through my Mad Barn store โ€” code 5%-OFF-FROM-LISA-M takes 5% off at checkout. Same disclosure as above: I earn a small commission if you buy through my link, and I only link what I actually feed.

Timothy is not the right call for every horse. A hard keeper, a lactating mare, a growing youngster, or a horse in hard work may genuinely need more calories and protein per mouthful than timothy gives. That’s when alfalfa earns its place โ€” mixed in, not as a replacement for the whole ration. Feeding timothy and alfalfa together is one of the oldest tricks in the book, because it lets you add energy without feeding a ration that’s rich all the way through.

Cutting stage matters more than the species name. Timothy cut at the boot stage โ€” before the seed head fully emerges โ€” is leafier, softer, and more nutritious than timothy cut late, when the plant has gone stemmy and lost feed value. Late-cut timothy can be so high in fiber and so low in digestibility that a horse picks through it and leaves the stems. When you’re buying, look at the bale, not just the label: green color, fine stems, leafy, clean smell, no dust when you break a flake open.

How I use timothy at Ballymoon Farm

Timothy is the steady base in my barn. Blue and Ruby each get 5 lb of timothy a day alongside 5 lb of alfalfa โ€” the timothy keeps the forage base moderate while the alfalfa adds the calories and protein they need for condition and, in Blue’s case, for breeding season. Ty and Z get timothy with their teff at night. It’s the hay I reach for when I want bulk and fiber without pushing weight on an easy keeper.

The timothy I am feeding now smells and looks great โ€” soft and leafy, and a pale green-grey. I believe the price is $32 a bale, though that will vary by location and region.

How much hay, and how to choose a bale

The rule of thumb is 1.5โ€“2% of body weight a day in forage, fed by weight, not by flake โ€” flakes vary too much to guess. For a 1,000 lb horse, that’s 15โ€“20 lb of hay a day, and timothy’s place in that is as the base you measure first and then add to.

When I’m choosing timothy, I look for:

  • Color: green to pale green, not yellow or brown and sun-bleached.
  • Stem: fine and pliable, not thick and woody. Bend a stem โ€” it should flex, not snap like a stick.
  • Leaf: leafy for a grass hay, with seed heads that aren’t fully mature and shattering.
  • Smell: clean and sweet. Dusty, musty, or sour means walk away.
  • Feel: a flake should break apart without a cloud of dust, and the horses should eat it without leaving a pile of stems behind.

And if the horse it’s for is metabolic or laminitis-prone, I test the lot before I commit to it. The name “timothy” is a starting point, not a lab result.

The bottom line

Timothy earned its reputation the slow way: by being the hay that the most horses, in the most situations, do well on. Moderate protein, moderate energy, high fiber, a sensible calcium-to-phosphorus ratio, and a consistency that lets you build a ration on it and adjust with alfalfa, a balancer, salt, and vitamin E as the individual horse needs.

It’s not magic, and it isn’t low-sugar by name alone. But as a foundation โ€” the hay you measure first, the hay you come back to when a horse needs steady rather than rich โ€” there isn’t a better baseline. That’s what “gold standard” means here: not the fanciest hay, but the one everything else gets judged against.

+ Show / Hide Comments

Share to:

Leave a Reply

Show more

A selection of our favorite articles, galleries, and updates.

Our Favorite Posts

don't miss

For more of our latest photos and inspiration, follow along on instagram at @instapony_. 

The Connemara Pony

ยฉ Redbud Ranch 2020 | Connemara Sport Horses and Ponies | photos by Lisa Martin | 

terms & Condtions | 

privacy Policy 

Intentionally Bred   with  People in Mind

Browns Valley, CA

BALLYMOON FARM

Connemara Sport horses & Ponies

error: This Content is protected.