
Dry pellets left her thirsty and anxious; wet alfalfa fines left her relaxed โ and about $50 a month cheaper.
I bought Standlee Forage Plus Gastric Support for a good reason, I used it for a while, and then I stopped. Not because it is a bad product. Because, in my barn, with my horses, a couple handfuls of alfalfa fines with water did the same job better โ and for a lot less money.
This is not a laboratory review. It is one breeder’s experience, with her own horses, in her own barn. Take it as that.
Standlee Forage Plus Gastric Support is an alfalfa-based forage pellet in a 40-pound bag. On the label it runs about 15โ16.7% crude protein, 1.0โ1.3% calcium, 0.2% phosphorus, and 200 ppm zinc, with no copper listed, and about 2.66 Mcal/kg of digestible energy on a dry-matter basis. The label rate is 0.5โ1% of body weight a day as a forage supplement.
What you are paying for, beyond the alfalfa itself, is the gastric-support package: alfalfa’s natural buffering, plus ButiPearl, plus yeast and probiotics for gut support. It is meant to be a forage-based way to support the stomach โ buffering acid, feeding the gut โ rather than a grain-based one.
At the rate I was feeding it, 1.25 pounds a day for one horse, a 40-pound bag lasts about 32 days for that horse.
Two different jobs, in my barn.
First, I bought it as a pre-ride snack for Z, who is in only the lightest training while the barn is being built. The idea is the usual one: a little forage in the stomach before work, to buffer acid and settle the horse, rather than riding on an empty stomach.
Second, Blue and Ruby were also getting 1.25 pounds a day each as gastric support in their rations โ Ruby while she was recovering, Blue as a generally chill stallion who did not need much in the way of calming down.
Here is the honest part, and the part that changed my mind.
On the Standlee, Z always seemed really thirsty. Dry pellets soak up gut water โ that is not a mystery, it is just what dry pellets do โ but she seemed thirstier on it, and, strangely, more anxious, not less. I expected a pre-ride snack to settle her. It did not settle her the way I wanted.
On a couple handfuls of alfalfa fines with water, she does better. More relaxed. The day I tried it before riding, she seemed very happy โ relaxed, comfortable, herself. A couple handfuls of alfalfa with water, before riding, and a horse that seems very happy afterwards: that is a hard result to argue with, in my barn.
I am not saying the Standlee made her anxious in some proven, scientific sense. I am saying what I saw, in the same horse, in the same light work, with the two snacks swapped: anxious and thirsty on the dry pellets, relaxed and happy on wet alfalfa fines. I trust what I see in my own horse.
I will be plain about this, because it is part of the decision: I am trying to save a little money right now, with a barn to build and the holidays coming. The Standlee was an easy place to look.
For Blue and Ruby together, at 1.25 pounds each a day, the Standlee was running roughly $65โ$70 a month. The same weight of alfalfa hay, at the roughly $0.23 a pound I pay at Tommi’s Hay Barn, is about $17 a month. That is roughly $50 a month saved, for close to a one-for-one swap on calcium, protein, and calories โ and I already keep alfalfa on hand for Ruby’s ration and for Blue and Barbie top-ups.
The alfalfa-fines snack for Z is cheaper still, because it is free: fines are what is left at the bottom of the alfalfa I already have. A couple handfuls, a splash of water, done.
Money was the driver for stopping the Standlee in the rations. But the Z snack is not only about money. If the expensive option had worked better for her, I would have kept buying it for that one job. It did not work better. The free option did.
I am finishing the Standlee I have, and I am not repurchasing it. When it is gone, alfalfa replaces it โ hay, in my case, since I already keep it and it is the simplest option. I have not settled cubes versus hay as the general replacement, but hay is the lean, because it is already here.
That means:
If you have a horse who is genuinely stressed, travelling, in hard work, or with a diagnosed ulcer history, a purpose-made gastric support product, used under your vet’s guidance, may be exactly right โ and I would not talk anyone out of what their vet has prescribed. I am not a vet, and this is not veterinary advice.
But if you are using a forage pellet mainly as a pre-ride stomach buffer for a quiet horse in light work, and you already have good alfalfa in the barn, it is worth trying the simple version first: a small amount of alfalfa, wet, before work. Watch the horse. If the horse is more relaxed and less thirsty on the wet alfalfa than on the dry pellets, believe the horse.
And watch the label, too. The Standlee I used lists no copper. A forage pellet is not a mineral balancer, and it should not be treated as one. If you drop a product like this, make sure the balancing is actually covered somewhere else in the ration โ in my case, by the balancer โ rather than assuming the pellet was doing it.
Standlee Forage Plus Gastric Support is a reasonable alfalfa pellet with a gut-support package, and I have no complaint about its quality. In my barn, it lost to alfalfa fines and water on the one job where I could compare them head to head โ Z’s pre-ride snack โ and it lost on cost on the ration job, by about $50 a month for two horses, with nothing my horses needed that alfalfa did not already give them.
So I finished the bag, I did not buy another, and the alfalfa stayed. Sometimes the simplest thing in the barn is the thing that works. In the end we decided the Standlee wasn’t worth the price โ it seemed to make everyone thirsty โ and went with a quarter flake of long-stem alfalfa instead.
For more of our latest photos and inspiration, follow along on instagram at @instapony_.
ยฉ Redbud Ranch 2020 | Connemara Sport Horses and Ponies | photos by Lisa Martin |
terms & Condtions |
privacy Policy
Intentionally Bred with People in Mind
Browns Valley, CA
+ Show / Hide Comments
Share to: