Intentionally Bred with  People in Mind

Browns Valley, CA

BALLYMOON FARM

Connemara Education

Choosing a Connemara Stallion for a Thoroughbred Mare

November 11, 2026

Watercolor illustration of Lady's Comet, a bay Thoroughbred mare, galloping

Why the Cross Works, When It Works

A Thoroughbred mare brings athleticism: gallop, blood, scope, and an engine that can run and jump. A Connemara stallion brings bone, a good brain, jumping technique, hardiness, and a temperament that keeps the whole package rideable. Put together well, you get a horse with enough blood to do the job and enough sense to enjoy doing it, in a size that suits a wide range of riders.

Put together badly, you get the worst of both: a hot, light, sharp horse with neither the bone nor the brain to hold up to the work. The cross does not fix anything by itself. It multiplies what is already there, good and bad alike. That is why the mare comes first.

Start With the Mare, Honestly

Before you look at a single stallion, write down your mare as she actually is, not as you hope she is.

Temperament first, because it is my first criterion in everything. Is she good-minded, easy to handle, and sensible? Does she settle after a fright, or stay up for an hour? A sharp or difficult mare will not reliably produce a calm foal just because the stallion is quiet. Temperament is partly inherited and partly made, and the mare gives the foal both its genes and its first months of life.

Conformation next. List her faults plainly: the long back, the straight shoulder, the light bone, the feet that need managing. A stallion can add bone and substance to a light mare, and improve a shoulder or a hind leg over a generation. He cannot fix unsoundness, and he cannot erase a serious structural fault in one cross. If your mare has a fault that would make her unsuitable for the work you want the foal to do, no stallion is the answer to that.

Then movement, soundness, and fertility history. Has she stayed sound in work? Has she carried and foaled before, and how did that go? Get a breeding soundness exam with your vet before you pay a booking fee, not after.

Then pedigree, read for what it is: information about the family, not a guarantee. Look for what the family actually did, verified, not just claimed. What the mare herself did matters more than a famous name three generations back.

A Worked Example: Barbie

Here is what that assessment looked like on one real mare: my own Thoroughbred mare, Lady’s Comet, known as Barbie. She is by Comet Shine out of Lady Coffee by Star Choice. Comet Shine also sired Courageous Comet, Becky Holder’s Olympic and World Equestrian Games partner, so the family has done the job at the very top level. That mattered to me, and I am proud of it, but it was not the reason I bred her. A famous relative does not make a broodmare. What a pedigree gives you is information about what a family tends to do, and the honest weight to put on it.

What I actually weighed, in order, was the list above. Temperament and handling first, conformation and soundness next, fertility history with the vet, and the pedigree last, as context rather than proof.

Barbie is sensitive but sensible, and tends towards overachieving. She has superior conformation and is approved Holsteiner and Oldenburg — in fact a premium mare with the AHHA.

The cross itself was the complement I described: Thoroughbred athleticism and gallop from Barbie’s side, bone, substance, jumping technique, and a steadier brain from Blue’s side.

And then the part no single breeding can give you: time. Barbie has been bred to Blue five times. That is not five identical foals, and I would never claim it was. It is five chances to learn what the cross actually produces, foal after foal, and to decide with evidence rather than hope whether to repeat it. A repeat cross earns its reputation one foal at a time. That is the honest version of a “proven nick.”

What a Stallion Can and Cannot Fix

A stallion can add: bone and substance, a steadier temperament, jumping technique, a better shoulder or hind leg, and in a Connemara cross, hardiness and a shorter back. He can move a mare’s foal toward the middle of the range you are aiming at.

A stallion cannot fix: a genuinely poor temperament, unsoundness, a fertility problem, or a serious conformation fault. He cannot give a foal a height you can count on, because height is not reliably predictable from one cross. He cannot fix a mare that should not be bred, and no pedigree, however fashionable, changes that.

Breeding is probabilities. The mare is the bigger part of the stack, and management, the feeding, handling, starting, and miles under saddle, decides whether the odds pay off.

Matching Temperament and Conformation

Match temperament to temperament. Do not breed a hot mare to a hot stallion and hope the foal comes out calm. Do not breed a dull mare to a dull stallion and hope for brilliance. I look for a stallion whose temperament complements the mare: steady where she is sharp, forward where she is laid back, always sensible. The foal needs a brain that suits the rider you have in mind. For my program that rider is an amateur, deliberately.

Match conformation by complement, not by clone. Write the mare’s three weakest points, and look for a stallion who is strong exactly there, without doubling up on her strengths until they become faults. A mare with plenty of length wants a stallion who is compact. A mare who is light of bone wants a stallion with real substance. And look at the stallion’s foals, not just the stallion. Foals are the evidence.

On size: a Connemara stallion at 14.3 hands on a 16-hand Thoroughbred mare will usually produce something in between, but “usually” is doing a lot of work in that sentence. If you need a particular height, ask about the heights of the stallion’s foals out of similar mares, and accept ranges, not orders.

Questions to Ask the Stallion Owner

Ask these in writing before you commit.

  • What other genetic tests has he had?
  • What is the current stud fee, and what exactly does it include? Ask for it in writing, with the date, because fees change between seasons.
  • Is semen available fresh cooled, frozen, or both, and on which collection days?
  • What are the contract terms: booking fee, when the balance is due, what happens if the mare does not catch, and what live foal guarantee, if any, applies? Read the whole contract before you pay anything.
  • Who pays for collection and shipping, and what shipping account or arrangements do I need?
  • What paperwork comes with the breeding: breeding certificate, registration eligibility, and anything the registry requires?
  • Can I see photos or video of the stallion’s foals out of mares like mine, and can I speak to a mare owner who has bred to him?

I do not print fee numbers, season dates, or facility details in articles, because those change. Ask for the current terms in writing and keep the reply with the contract.

The Vet, the Timing, and the Honest Ending

Talk to your reproductive vet early, before the season, not the week your mare comes into heat. Your vet will plan the breeding soundness exam, the timing, the ultrasounds, and the semen order, and will tell you honestly whether your mare is a good candidate this year. Some mares need a year off. Some need treatment first. Some should not be bred at all. Better to hear it in February than in May, after a booking fee.

And be realistic about the result. A good cross gives you a foal with the odds in its favor: the brain, the bone, the athleticism, and the temperament to do the job. It does not give you a finished horse. The foal still needs handling, feeding, starting, and miles, and the rider still needs to suit the horse. The best mating I ever made was an honest mare, a complementary stallion, a test result in the file, and years of ordinary good management. That is the whole secret.

+ Show / Hide Comments

Share to:

Leave a Reply

Show more

A selection of our favorite articles, galleries, and updates.

Our Favorite Posts

don't miss

For more of our latest photos and inspiration, follow along on instagram at @instapony_. 

The Connemara Pony

© Redbud Ranch 2020 | Connemara Sport Horses and Ponies | photos by Lisa Martin | 

terms & Condtions | 

privacy Policy 

Intentionally Bred   with  People in Mind

Browns Valley, CA

BALLYMOON FARM

Connemara Sport horses & Ponies

error: This Content is protected.